Institution of Speaker in Parliament: A UPSC Mains Overview

Posted by on

 


1) History and Legacy

  • The office of the Speaker in India is inspired from the British parliamentary system, where the Speaker of the House of Commons evolved as the defender of parliamentary privileges against the Crown.

  • In India, the office was first introduced under the Government of India Act, 1919, with the Speaker presiding over the Central Legislative Assembly.

  • Ganesh Vasudev Mavalankar became the first Speaker of the Lok Sabha in 1952, often called the “Father of the Lok Sabha.”

2) Taken From (Sources of Inspiration)

  • Borrowed from the UK House of Commons tradition where the Speaker symbolizes neutrality and protects the rights of the House.

  • Embedded in the Indian Constitution under Articles 93–97 (Lok Sabha) and Articles 178–187 (State Assemblies).

3) First Among Firsts

  • G.V. Mavalankar – first Speaker of independent India (1952–56).

  • Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan (then Vice President) described the Speaker as “the very embodiment of freedom and liberty of Parliament.”

  • Meira Kumar (2009–14) – first woman Speaker of Lok Sabha.

  • Om Birla (2019–present) – current Speaker, known for stricter discipline and modernization efforts.

4) Nomination and Election

  • Elected by members of the Lok Sabha from among themselves, by a simple majority of those present and voting.

  • Ruling party usually nominates the Speaker, but by convention, election is uncontested.

  • Holds office from date of election until next Lok Sabha is dissolved.

  • Resigns by writing to the Deputy Speaker.

  • Can be removed by a resolution of the Lok Sabha passed by an absolute majority (majority of total membership).

5) Powers and Functions

  • Presiding Officer: Conducts business, maintains order, and ensures decorum.

  • Interpretation of Rules: Decides on procedural matters under Rules of Procedure.

  • Disciplinary Role: Can suspend members for disorderly conduct.

  • Certification Authority: Decides whether a Bill is a Money Bill (Article 110).

  • Anti-Defection Powers: Decides questions of disqualification under the Tenth Schedule.

  • Administrative Role: Head of Lok Sabha Secretariat.

  • Link with President and Rajya Sabha: Communicates House resolutions, summons, prorogues sessions.

6) Changes Over Time

  • From a symbolic chair in colonial times → evolved into a powerful constitutional authority post-independence.

  • After Anti-Defection Law (1985), Speaker’s powers increased, but concerns about impartiality grew.

  • Greater involvement in parliamentary committees and modernization of proceedings.

7) Judicial Pronouncements and Committees

  • Kihoto Hollohan Case (1992) – upheld Speaker’s role in anti-defection but allowed judicial review of his decisions.

  • Nabam Rebia Case (2016) – Supreme Court held that the Speaker cannot decide on disqualification if a motion for his own removal is pending.

  • Tenth Schedule reviews – several committees (Dinesh Goswami Committee, 1990; National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution, 2002) suggested that anti-defection powers should be given to an independent tribunal instead of Speaker.

8) Best Person Examples

  • G.V. Mavalankar (1952–56) – set high standards of neutrality.

  • Balram Jakhar (1980–89) – longest-serving Speaker, introduced modern parliamentary practices.

  • Somnath Chatterjee (2004–09) – refused to resign despite party pressure, upholding dignity of office.

  • Meira Kumar (2009–14) – promoted women’s participation and parliamentary diplomacy.



9) Global Comparison

  • UK – Speaker resigns from political party, remains strictly neutral.

  • USA – Speaker of House of Representatives is a highly partisan position (leader of majority party).

  • India – constitutionally neutral, but in practice, accused of being partisan towards ruling party due to political background.

10) Way Forward

  • Impartiality – Speaker should resign from party once elected, like in the UK.

  • Independent Tribunal for Defection Cases – to reduce conflict of interest.

  • Greater transparency – decisions on Money Bills and disqualification should be subject to clear criteria.

  • Strengthening Parliamentary Committees – Speaker can play a bigger role in making Parliament more deliberative and less disruptive.

  • Use of Technology – e-Parliament, digital records, AI-enabled language translation to ensure inclusivity.

Conclusion

The Speaker is called the “guardian of the Lok Sabha”. The legacy of neutrality set by the first Speakers has been eroded by partisanship over time. Restoring credibility requires reforms in disqualification powers, more transparency in decision-making, and adapting to global best practices. A robust and impartial Speaker is essential for safeguarding the dignity and effectiveness of Indian democracy.

Comments

Post a Comment