India's Inequality Paradox: World Bank Hails Declining Consumption Gaps and Poverty Eradication Amidst Persistent Concerns Over Deepening Income & Wealth Concentration

Posted by on

Gini Coefficient representing income or wealth distribution within a population.

 Introduction: Inequality refers to the uneven distribution of income, wealth and consumption among individuals or households within an economy. A recent World Bank (WB) report ("India Poverty and Equity Brief: April 2025") claims that India has eradicated extreme poverty. 

Findings of the Report:

  • According to the report, consumption inequality has significantly reduced since 2011-12, with respect to consumption patterns of the population.
  • The report has placed India among the four least unequal countries in terms of gini coefficient, a measure of inequality.
Dimensions of Inequality:
  • Economic Inequality:
  1. Income Inequality: Disparities in terms of wages, salaries and profits received by individuals or households over time, measured by gini coefficient, Lorenz Curve, Kuznet Curve etc.
  2. Wealth Inequality: Disparities in terms of wealth ownership, including financial assets like stocks and shares, physical assets such as land, house, gold etc.
  3. Consumption Inequality: Disparities in terms of goods and services consumed by individuals or households.
  4. Inequality of Opportunity: Disparities in terms of availability of sufficient opportunities to enhance one's economic status and social mobility.
  • Social Inequality:
  1. Caste Inequality: Unique to India, caste inequality is deeply rooted in Indian society, affecting access to education and employment.
  2. Gender Inequality: Unequal treatment of men and women based on their gender identity, influencing economic status (wage gap, lower female labour force participation), educational attainment, health (maternal mortality rate, prevalence of anaemia among women), political participation (underrepresentation in legislative bodies).
  3. Racial Inequality: Discrimination against ethnic minorities, experienced by tribal people and people from northeast India.
  4. Religious Inequality: Marginalization of religious minorities often culminating in communal violence e.g 2020 Delhi riots.
  • Political Inequality:
  1. Unequal Representation: Underrepresentation of certain groups in political institutions (legislature, executive and judiciary) contrary to their demographic size.
  2. Disparities in Political Voice: Differential abilities of various groups to voice their concerns, often skewed towards the affluent and wealthy.
  3. Disproportionate Impact of Policies: Policies may disproportionately impact individuals and communities based on economic status and social capital.
  4. Erosion of Democratic Principles: Caused by concentration of political power which undermines equal civic participation.
  • Geographic Inequality:
  1. Rural-Urban Divide: Significant disparities in access to quality services (health, education), infrastructure (road, schools, transport) and employment opportunities.
  2. Inter-State Disparities: Differences in terms of development indicators e.g per capita income, HDI (Human Development Index) etc.
  3. Intra-State Disparities: Uneven development within a state, often seen between developed and developing regions.
  4. Unequal Access to Capital: Disparities in terms of investment capital e.g Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is often skewed towards developed states such as Maharashtra, Karnataka and Gujarat.
Impacts of Inequality:
  • Economic Impacts:
  1. Hinders inclusive economic growth leading to reduced aggregate demand, suboptimal human capital development, limited innovation and entrepreneurship and fiscal instability. For example, top 1% owns over 40% of country's wealth while the bottom 50% owns merely 3% (Oxfam).
  2. Promotes inefficient resource utilization e.g despite an increase in non-tax revenues through initiatives like the National Monetization Pipeline (NMP), generating ₹6 lakh crore over FY2022-25 remains a challenge.
  3. Necessitates larger government expenditure on social safety nets, increase in subsidies and loan waivers, further widening the fiscal deficit.
  4. Increases poverty and aggravates the vulnerability of marginalized groups e.g the World Bank estimates that approximately 129 million Indians were living in extreme poverty in 2024.
  • Social Impacts:
  1. Instigates social tensions, generating resentment among the marginalized communities and aggravating their alienation. This manifests itself in growing crime rates and demands for secessionism.
  2. Weakens social cohesion leading to erosion of trust in the administration. This only serves to worsen the division among different communities.
  3. Creates a fertile ground for the seeds of identity politics to grow as different groups seek to secure their ownership of limited resources.
  4. Intensifies health (prevalence of stunting and wasting), education (learning gaps after COVID-19 pandemic) and gender disparities with women often bearing a disproportionate burden. According to NFHS-5, 59.1% of adolescent girls in India are anaemic.
  • Political Impacts:
  1. Undermines democracy as high enonomic inequality enables the rich and powerful to influence policy-making i.e crony capitalism. This reduces accountability of politicians to the electorate.
  2. Fuels populist movements and political polarization as dissatisfied groups seek radical changes, potentially leading to instability.
  3. Strains administrative capacity as governments struggle to manage social unrest and deliver services efficiently to a highly segmented population.
  • Environmental Impacts:
  1. Promotes environmental injustice as lower income households disproportionaltely suffer from harmful air and water pollution. Urban air pollution accounted for 6.7 million premature deaths in 2019, primarily affecting the poor and marginalized.
  2. Increases vulnerability to the impacts of climate change (extreme weather events, droughts, floods) due to limited adaptive capacity and lack of adequate housing and insurance.
  3. Causes unequal access to clean resources including clean drinking water, sanitation and clean energy sources.
Steps to Reduce Inequality in India:
  • Constitutional and Legal Framework:
  1. Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP): Articles 38 and 39 specifically mandate the state to create a social order based on justice and minimize inequalities.
  2. Fundamental Rights: Article 14-18 guarantee the Right to Equality, prohibiting discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth.
  3. Anti-discrimination Laws: Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 and the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
  • Economic Measures:
  1. MGNREGA guarantees 100 days of wage employment in a financial year to rural households.
  2. NULM and DAY-NULM seek to mitigate the vulnerbility of urban poor households by providing them self-employment opportunities.
  3. Skill India Mission, PM Vishwakarma Yojana and Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana (PMMY) promote skill development and entrepreneurship.
  • Financial Inclusion:
  1. Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) facilitates universal access to banking facilities with a focus on basic savings accounts for the unbanked.
  2. Aadhar-linked Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) ensures transparent and efficient allocation of subsidies and welfare benefits directly to the beneficiaries' bank accounts.
  3. Pradhan Mantri Jeevan Jyoti Bima Yojana (PMJJBY) and Pradhan Mantri Suraksha Bima Yojana (PMSBY) provide affordable life and  accident insurance schemes.
  • Human Development:
  1. Right to Education (RTE) Act, 2009 ensures free and compulsory education for all children aged 6 to 14, providing universal access to schooling.
  2. Ayushman Bharat-Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PM-JAY) provides health insurance cover of ₹5 lakh/family/year for secondary and tertiary care hospitalization.
  3. Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY)- Urban and Gramin provide affordable housing for all by 2022 with provisions for women beneficiaries and persons with disabilities.
  • Regional Development:
  1. Aspirational Districts Programme, launched by NITI Aayog, focuses on rapid transformation of 112 most underdeveloped districts across various development indicators.
  2. Special Category Status for some states rectifies historical and structural backwardness of certain regions.
  3. PM Gati Shakti Master Plan facilitates integrated planning and coordinated implementation of infrastructure connectivity projects across various ministries.
Challenges in Reducing Inequality in India:
  • India's economic growth has not generated adequated formal, well-paying jobs to absorb the growing workforce.
  • Agriculture sector suffers from low productivity, climate vulnerability and inadequate market linkages, perpetuating rural poverty and rural-urban income gap.
  • Prevalence of informal sector characterized by low wages, no social security, poor working conditions and high vulnerability.
  • Persistent social exclusion leads to unequal access to quality public services.
  • Poor implementation of government schemes due corruption, bureaucratic inefficiencies and leakages.
Way Forward:
  • Promoting labour-intensive sectors, strengthening MSMEs, revitalizing maufacturing and investing in green sectors.
  • Progressive taxation and fiscal policy encompassing wealth and inheritance taxes, reducing indirect tax burden on the poor, and curbing tax evasion.
  • Investing in human capital and social capital by enhancing public education system, focusing on early childhood education and facilitating universal access to quality healthcare.
Conclusion: India's aspirations to become a truly developed and equitable society depend on its ability to foster inclusive growth that provides equal opportunities and a dignified life to every citizen, ensuring that progress is not just about aggregate numbers but about shared prosperity and social justice.

Comments

Post a Comment